Frugal Recipes: Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie (Your Hips Won’t Thank You)

Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie

My mouth is watering!

I am not a pie person. I actually kind of detest pie crust. However, I guess you can say that while I’m not a pie crust fan, I can be convinced (you know by twisting my arm or setting a plate in front of me) to eat pie filling.

My mama taught me to clean my plate, a habit that unfortunately has not died, despite the reassurance from my ever-growing hips that I totally would be just fine if I left some (if not most) food on my plate.

This is the main reason why I don’t really bake pies. As a member of the Clean Your Plate club, I take offense to any recipe that I know I’ll only partially enjoy.

Mainly it’s a time thing. If I have to spend the time to make the pie crust, roll it out, prepare the filling, crimp the edges etc…I definitely would rather spend that time on something “lick the crumbs” worthy.

However…chocolate chip cookies are probably my single biggest weakness (well…good ones are). I’ll eat a chocolate chip cookie in just about any form:

  1. Dough
  2. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream
  3. Chocolate Chip Cookies
  4. Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches
  5. Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake
  6. You get the picture

So it stands to reason that when I saw this Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie recipe from Bakerella (btw, she’s not feeling too well so go send her some love), my dislike of pie crust was NOT going to be holding me back from at least attempting it. I mean who knows? Chocolate Chip Cookies really do make everything better! Could they even make pie crust worth the effort?

Luckily, this recipe calls for pre-made refrigerated pie dough…so other than slapping the pie crust in the pie plate, it actually required very little effort.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie

You like how fancy I make my pie crust? It's a talent, I think I have a real knack for it!

(Yes MIL, that is your pie plate. I will give it back to you…soon? BTW, thanks for letting me “borrow” it! ;) )

The cookie dough filling was even easier than making actual cookies and required even less ingredients.

Cookie Dough Pie

Mmmm, it's a wonder I didn't eat all that batter!

The entire pie was in the oven in less than 10 minutes. At this point I’m thinking, wow…even if it is absolutely disgusting, that was super easy!

Cookie Dough Pie

Let's Dig in!

55-60 minutes in a 325 degree oven and you are presented with this:

We let it sit for a bit, and then we dug in.

The verdict?

Well, I still don’t like pie crust. I don’t necessarily mind the bottom of the pie-pie crust, but the actual edges? Yuck, not my cup of tea (my hips say THANK YOU!). However, this pie was so super easy to whip up and dirtied very few dishes…so I’m calling this one a winner.

It’s also really quite economical as far as pies go. AND it’s even better the second day (in my opinion…husband likes it fresh from the oven!).

We have had the pie with homemade vanilla ice cream and that is To.Die.For!

Definitely try this pie, you won’t regret it!


Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie

from Bakerella


  • 1 unbaked 9 inch pie shell (make it yourself or buy it. I say just buy it)
  • 2 large eggs
  • 1/2 cup all purpose flour
  • 1/2 cup white sugar
  • 1/2 cup brown sugar
  • 3/4 cup butter
  • 1 cup chocolate chips
  • nuts optional


  1. Preheat  your oven to 325
  2. Whip your eggs until they are light and fluffy (I used my Kitchen Aid).
  3. Add flour, both sugars and butter and beat until thoroughly mixed
  4. Add chocolate chips and nuts if you like
  5. Put pie crust into your pie plate (or your Mother in Law’s pie plate)
  6. Pour filling into pie crust
  7. Bake for 55-60 minutes
  8. Let sit for at least 30 minutes or so. It will “set” a bit.
  9. Enjoy!

You don’t want the nutritional info on this one. I promise.

Let me know if you make this! If you want to print this recipe you can click the print friendly button below and just print the ingredients and directions (tutorial here).

If you enjoyed this, please consider sharing it on Facebook, Twitter or Stumble Upon using the buttons below!

Tell us what you think:

  1. Mama Kelly aka Jia says

    Personally I love pie crust, especially the edges. And this cookie dough pie looks like a great excuse to eat some.

  2. Sdanceqt says

    Sounds yummy. I am not a fan of pie crust either – I usually gut the pie and leave the crust. Dead give away that I was sneaking some out of the tin… Maybe and oreo crust would make this super good!

  3. Niki says

    Incredible and easy recipe, thank you for sharing!!! I just ran into one problem (though it still turned out ok in the end), the filling bubbled up and overflowed while in the oven (thank goodness I baked it on a cookie sheet)! I used a Stop n’ Shop brand 9-inch unbaked pie shell, I guess the type I bought was too shallow, I’ll be getting the deep-dish style next time I make this.

Comment Policy

I'd love to hear what you have to say! Be kind, be respectful and be constructive. If you wouldn't say it to my face and in my home...don't say it here. We do have a ZERO tolerance comment policy here and meanies, trolls and spammers get deleted!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>